What Size Wall Anchors to Use (No More Guesswork)
Choosing the wrong wall anchor can wreck your drywall or send your shelf crashing down. This guide shows exactly what size wall anchors to use — and which screws work with them — even if you’ve never touched a drill before.
- Difficulty: Beginner
- Time Required: 10–20 min (per install)
- Skill Level: First-time DIYer
- Tools Needed: Drill, anchors, screws, stud finder, level
Tools & Materials
Tools
- Cordless Drill — for drilling pilot holes and driving screws
- Drill Bit Set — match the bit to your anchor size
- Stud Finder — check if you’re hitting drywall or a stud
- Measuring Tape — for accurate layout
- Level — keeps everything aligned and straight
- Screwdriver (Manual or Electric) — for final tightening or shallow-depth installs
- Pencil — for marking anchor points
Materials
- Wall Anchor Assortment Kit — includes plastic, self-drilling, and toggle anchors
- Wood or Sheet Metal Screws — compatible with your anchors
- Toggle Bolts (Optional) — for heavy-duty items like TV mounts
- Painter’s Tape (Optional) — helps mark and protect wall during layout
Just a heads up: Some of the links in this guide are affiliate links, which means we may earn a small commission if you buy through them (at no extra cost to you). We only recommend tools we trust — thanks for supporting Gold Team Home!
Step-by-Step Instructions
1. Know What Type of Wall You’re Drilling Into
Before you choose an anchor size, you need to know what you’re anchoring into.
- Drywall (most common) — soft, thin, and needs anchors to grip
- Stud (wood behind drywall) — no anchor needed, just screws
- Plaster, brick, or concrete — needs masonry anchors or toggle bolts
Use a stud finder to scan your wall and mark whether you’re hitting hollow drywall or a solid stud.
2. Match Anchor Type to the Job
Choose your wall anchor based on what you’re hanging and how much it weighs.
| Item Type | Recommended Anchor | Weight Capacity |
|---|---|---|
| Small decor (<10 lbs) | Plastic expansion anchor + #6–#8 screw | Up to 15 lbs |
| Medium decor (10–25 lbs) | Self-drilling drywall anchor | 25–50 lbs |
| Shelves, mirrors (25+ lbs) | Toggle bolt or molly bolt | 50–100+ lbs (toggle) |
| Into stud (any weight) | Wood screw only — no anchor needed | 100+ lbs |
Beginner Tip: If in doubt, go stronger than needed — overkill is better than wall damage.
3. Pick the Right Anchor Size
Anchor packaging often lists the compatible screw size and wall thickness it works with. But here’s a cheat sheet:
| Anchor Size | Compatible Screw | Wall Type |
|---|---|---|
| Small (3/16″) | #6–#8 screw | Drywall or plaster |
| Medium (1/4″) | #8–#10 screw | Drywall, studs |
| Large (3/8″+) | #10–#12 screw or toggle | Drywall, concrete |
Wall anchor kits usually include the right screw — but double check before installing.
4. Drill the Right Pilot Hole (if Needed)
Some anchors (like plastic or toggle) require a pilot hole. Others (like self-drilling anchors) do not.
- Check your anchor packaging for the correct drill bit size
- Use painter’s tape on the bit as a depth guide if needed
- Drill slowly and straight to avoid wobble
Tip: Pilot holes should be just slightly smaller than the anchor for a tight grip.
5. Install the Anchor
Follow the instructions for your anchor type:
- Plastic anchor: Push or lightly tap into the hole until flush
- Self-drilling anchor: Screw directly into the drywall until snug
- Toggle bolt: Insert through the hole with wings collapsed, then tighten
Don’t overtighten — anchors can spin or strip if forced.
6. Drive in the Screw
Place your item’s bracket or mounting hardware, then insert the screw through it into the anchor.
- Use a manual screwdriver or low torque on your drill
- Stop when the screw feels tight and holds firmly — no need to bury it
✅ You’ve now chosen the right wall anchor, matched it to the proper screw, and installed it safely — without the guesswork.
Explore More DIY Projects
Browse our full library of beginner-friendly guides — from quick upgrades to full weekend projects, all designed to help you build confidence and make your home your own.
Pro Tips
✅ Pro Tips
✅ Use a screw sizing gauge
Some anchor kits include a sizing card — use it to match your screw perfectly to the anchor and avoid guesswork.✅ Mark your drill bit with painter’s tape
Wrap tape around the bit to match the anchor depth — this prevents drilling too deep or punching through the wall.✅ Start with a test anchor
If you’ve never used anchors before, try one on a scrap board or behind a picture frame to get the feel.✅ Always double-check weight ratings
Every anchor has a max load — exceeding it can cause long-term failure even if it holds at first.
❌ Common Mistakes to Avoid
❌ Using drywall anchors in studs
If you hit a stud, don’t use an anchor — just drive a screw directly into the wood. Anchors won’t hold in solid material.❌ Oversizing the pilot hole
A hole that’s too big makes your anchor spin or fall out. Always match the drill bit to the anchor body, not the screw.❌ Overtightening the screw
Too much torque can strip the anchor or crush drywall behind it — tighten until firm, then stop.❌ Skipping the level or measuring tape
Even if the anchor holds well, your item will look sloppy if it’s crooked or misaligned. Take your time.
Essentials: What You’ll Need
These tools make caulking maintenance simple, even if it’s your first time handling sealant. Make this job clean, easy, and mess-free with the right gear:
Need Better Tools?
Upgrading your gear makes every project easier (and way more fun). We’ve rounded up the best drills, levels, saws, and more — all tested for real-world DIY use.
Level Up Your DIY Skills – One Weekend at a Time
Join our free DIY email list and get weekly tips, tools, and guides to tackle your next home project like a pro. No spam, just real help.