New! DIY Project Planner. Plan smarter, skip the spreadsheets. Start Your Free Trial Today →
Laminate vs Vinyl vs Engineered Wood: Best DIY Flooring Options Compared
Laminate vs Vinyl vs Engineered Wood: Best DIY Flooring Options Compared
Which Flooring Is Right for Your DIY Project?
When you are planning a flooring upgrade, the choices can feel overwhelming. Laminate, vinyl plank, engineered wood. They all look great on display, but each one performs very differently once it’s in your home.
The right flooring for you depends on your budget, the room you are updating, and how much DIY effort you are willing to put in. In this guide, we’ll break down the three most popular DIY-friendly flooring options, compare their pros and cons, and share specific product recommendations to help you choose confidently.
Affiliate Disclosure: Some of the links below are affiliate links. If you make a purchase using these links, Gold Team Home may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for supporting our site and allowing us to keep publishing helpful DIY content.
Laminate Flooring
What it is:
Laminate flooring is made from a fiberboard core topped with a photographic image layer and sealed with a protective wear layer. It mimics the look of hardwood at a much lower cost.
Why DIYers like it:
- Affordable entry point into a new floor
- Extremely wide range of colors and textures
- Most products use click-lock installation, no glue required
- Scratch resistant and good for moderate traffic
Limitations:
- Not waterproof — will swell if it gets wet
- Cannot be refinished
- Requires a sound-reducing underlayment to avoid a hollow feel
Best spaces: Bedrooms, living rooms, hallways, and other dry areas.
Popular Options:
- Pergo is the most trusted brand in laminate — known for durability
Must-Have Tools & Add-ons:
- Flooring installation kit with spacers and tapping block (Amazon)
- Foam underlayment roll for sound control and moisture barrier
Luxury Vinyl Plank (LVP / LVT)
What it is:
Luxury Vinyl Plank (LVP) or Tile (LVT) is made from multiple layers of PVC vinyl with a rigid core and a textured wear layer. It’s designed to replicate wood or stone but with waterproof performance.
Why DIYers like it:
- Completely waterproof, even in bathrooms and basements
- Scratch and dent resistant
- Soft underfoot compared to laminate
- Easy click-lock installation (some options are glue-down for pros)
Limitations:
- Can fade in areas with heavy sunlight
- Heavier than laminate, harder to cut without the right tool
- Premium brands can be pricier
Best spaces: Kitchens, bathrooms, laundry rooms, and basements.
Top Picks:
- Lucida Surfaces Luxury Vinyl Plank — our “Best Overall,” fully waterproof and easy to install.
- Home Aesthetics Interlocking Vinyl Floor Planks — best value pick.
Helpful Tools:
- Vinyl flooring cutter for clean cuts
- Knee pads for installation comfort
Engineered Wood Flooring
What it is:
Engineered wood flooring is real hardwood on top of multiple plywood or HDF layers. This construction gives you the beauty of hardwood with greater stability than solid planks.
Why DIYers like it:
- Real wood surface with authentic look and feel
- More stable in humidity compared to solid hardwood
- Some products can be refinished once or twice
- Click-lock versions exist, though some require glue or nails
Limitations:
- Sensitive to standing water
- Higher upfront cost than laminate or vinyl
- Limited refinishing compared to solid wood
Best spaces: Living rooms, dining rooms, and bedrooms where you want a real wood look.
Installation Tip:
- Use a moisture meter for subfloor readings before installing to prevent warping
Recommended Engineered Wood Products:
- Bruce Engineered Hardwood Flooring – classic American brand with a range of finishes
- CFA INDUSTRIAL CORP – premium natural wood look
- Mullican Engineered Hardwood – great mid-range option
Must-Have Tools:
- Floor nailer or stapler (if nail-down type)
- Moisture meter — worth its weight in gold
Need help mapping your flooring project? Use our DIY Project Planner to track your measurements, materials, and budget before you shop or install.
Quick Comparison Chart
| Feature | Laminate | Vinyl Plank (LVP) | Engineered Wood |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cost | $ to $$ (budget) | $$ to $$$ (mid/high) | $$$ (investment) |
| Durability | Good, scratch resistant (dry areas) | Excellent, waterproof | Excellent but water sensitive |
| Appearance | Photo layer imitation | Highly realistic textures | Real hardwood veneer |
| Installation | Easy click-lock | Easy click-lock | Moderate (floating, nail, or glue) |
| Moisture Resistance | Low | Excellent | Moderate |
| Resale Value | Low | Medium | High |
How to Choose the Best Option
- If you are on a budget, laminate is the easiest way to refresh your floors quickly. It gives you style without breaking the bank.
- If you need moisture protection, vinyl plank is your safest bet. It will hold up in basements, kitchens, and bathrooms where other flooring fails.
- If you want real wood and higher resale value, engineered hardwood is worth the investment. It adds authenticity and boosts your home’s value.
Other factors to consider
- Pets and kids: Vinyl plank holds up best to claws, spills, and heavy use.
- DIY skill level: Laminate and vinyl are easiest to install for beginners. Engineered wood requires more care.
- Long-term plan: If you are selling your home soon, engineered wood increases resale appeal. If you plan to stay long term, vinyl may provide better durability.
- Planning your install? Use the DIY Project Planner to track tools, materials, and budget in one place.
Key Takeaways
- Laminate is budget friendly and easy for beginners but avoid it in high moisture areas.
- Vinyl plank is the most versatile choice with 100% waterproof protection.
- Engineered wood gives you real hardwood beauty with better stability than solid planks.
- All three can be DIY installed with click-lock systems and basic tools.
- Match your flooring choice to your budget, lifestyle, and long-term goals for best results.
Related Posts:
- Flat, Satin, or Semi-Gloss? How to Choose the Right Paint Finish for Every Room
- DIY Project Planner
- Pro Tools Worth the Splurge
